• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Finance Train

Finance Train

High Quality tutorials for finance, risk, data science

  • Home
  • Data Science
  • CFA® Exam
  • PRM Exam
  • Tutorials
  • Careers
  • Products
  • Login

Why Basel I (1988 Accord) Needed to be Replaced?

Basel II, PRM Exam, PRM Exam III

This lesson is part 4 of 8 in the course Basel II - An Overview

The rules of the original 1988 Accord are generally acknowledged to be flawed for various reasons, discussed below:

  • Credit risk assessment under Basel I is not risk-sensitive enough. Capital need assessment under Basel I accord was not being able to differentiate between banks with lower risks and banks with higher risks. For example, exposure on a company with AAA rating and a company with B rating are treated identically for the purpose of capital adequacy. Both will be placed in 100% risk weight category, although risks associated with them would be quite different.

  • It promotes financial decision-making on the basis of regulatory constraints rather than on the basis of economic opportunities. Capital requirement for all corporate accounts being the same, it encouraged financing of assets with more risk for higher returns. Whereas a sound decision should take into account risk and return characteristics of an asset, it was discouraged, as capital requirements were not differentiated based on risk characteristics of assets.
  • It did not recognize the role of credit risk mitigants, such as credit derivatives, securitizations, collaterals and guarantees, in reducing credit risk.
  • The accord does not appropriately take maturity factors into effect. For example, revolving credit arrangements with a term of less than one year do not require any regulatory capital while a short-term, facility with 366 days to maturity bears the same capital charge as any long-term facility.
  • Lastly, the Accord does not address complex issues such as portfolio effects, even though credit risk in any large portfolio is bound to be partially offset by diversification.

These shortcomings would lead to a distorted assessment of risk and capital, and therefore, in 1996, the Basel Committee declared its intentions to build a new capital adequacy framework, known as Basel II.

The fundamental objectives to revise the 1988 Accord have been:

  • To develop a framework that would strengthen the soundness and stability of the international banking system
  • To ensure that it does not become a source of competitive inequality among internationally active banks and yet have a capital adequacy regulation that is sufficiently consistent
  • To help promote the adoption of stronger risk management practices by the banking industry.

Basel II was released on June 26, 2004.

Previous Lesson

‹ Basel Accord – 1996 Market Risk Amendment

Next Lesson

Overview of Basel II Accord ›

Join Our Facebook Group - Finance, Risk and Data Science

Posts You May Like

How to Improve your Financial Health

CFA® Exam Overview and Guidelines (Updated for 2021)

Changing Themes (Look and Feel) in ggplot2 in R

Coordinates in ggplot2 in R

Facets for ggplot2 Charts in R (Faceting Layer)

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

In this Course

  • Introduction to Basel Capital Accord
  • The 1988 Basel Accord (Basel I)
  • Basel Accord – 1996 Market Risk Amendment
  • Why Basel I (1988 Accord) Needed to be Replaced?
  • Overview of Basel II Accord
  • Basel II – Capital Charge for Credit Risk
  • Basel II – Standardised Approach for Credit Risk
  • Basel II – Internal Ratings Based (IRB) Approach

Latest Tutorials

    • Data Visualization with R
    • Derivatives with R
    • Machine Learning in Finance Using Python
    • Credit Risk Modelling in R
    • Quantitative Trading Strategies in R
    • Financial Time Series Analysis in R
    • VaR Mapping
    • Option Valuation
    • Financial Reporting Standards
    • Fraud
Facebook Group

Membership

Unlock full access to Finance Train and see the entire library of member-only content and resources.

Subscribe

Footer

Recent Posts

  • How to Improve your Financial Health
  • CFA® Exam Overview and Guidelines (Updated for 2021)
  • Changing Themes (Look and Feel) in ggplot2 in R
  • Coordinates in ggplot2 in R
  • Facets for ggplot2 Charts in R (Faceting Layer)

Products

  • Level I Authority for CFA® Exam
  • CFA Level I Practice Questions
  • CFA Level I Mock Exam
  • Level II Question Bank for CFA® Exam
  • PRM Exam 1 Practice Question Bank
  • All Products

Quick Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us

CFA Institute does not endorse, promote or warrant the accuracy or quality of Finance Train. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.

Copyright © 2021 Finance Train. All rights reserved.

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us